Russia says it has slowed inflation and kept unemployment steady despite the West's sanctions. 2 experts break down Putin's spin on the numbers.
inflationrate slowed to 0.1% on-month in May while prices fell for the week ending June 3.
- From January to April, the country's
unemploymentheld steady at around 4%.
At a regular meeting with his government on Tuesday, Russian President
Unemployment, Putin said, is at the "lowest historical level in
"The number of jobless, far from increasing, even decreased a little," the Russian leader added, calling it "a very serious achievement."
The developments come more than three months after Russia invaded Ukraine on February 24. The country is facing hard-hitting international sanctions and boycotts — but Putin's statements indicate Russia's
However, a foreign affairs analyst told Insider it's possible the statistics have been manipulated.
"The Russian government obviously has an incentive to try to hide the economic impact of Western sanctions," said Andrew Lohsen, a fellow in the Europe, Russia, and Eurasia Program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. "So if there was a way to creatively account for joblessness and try to hide the true impact of unemployment, then I think that's something that the Russian government will absolutely resort to. It makes perfect sense," he said.
Some economists are already painting a less optimistic picture of Russia's economy. In May, Robin Brooks, the chief economist at the Institute of International Finance (IIF) trade group, tweeted that "Russia's economy is imploding." It's expecting to see a GDP collapse of 30% by the end of 2022.
For now, Russia has managed to prop up its economy. It's expected to rake in more money from oil and sales gas in 2022 than it did last year, thanks to soaring energy prices, according to Bloomberg Economics. At the same time, it's enacting a series of policy moves to soften the blow of sanctions for its populace by taming inflation and preserving jobs.
Here's how Russia has managed to put the brakes on inflation and stave off massive unemployment so far.
'Financial repression' is propping the ruble up — and capping consumer prices
Russia's inflation rate soared after it invaded Ukraine, rising 17.1% on-year in May, according to Rosstat. But while weekly price increases peaked in early March, they have been slowing ever since. Prices were lower on-week for the week ending June 3, per Rosstat.
In statement on June 2, Russia's
Moscow has managed to prop up the
A drop in exports also helped to support the ruble as importers now have less demand for foreign currencies, the Russian central bank wrote in a May report, as reported by Interfax.
"I would say that the trading price of ruble is not the best indicator of the health of the Russian economy, but more for the average Russian person who gets paid in rubles and spends in rubles," Lohsen told Insider.
Instead, it's more a reflection of how much the Russian economy has changed since the invasion of Ukraine triggered sweeping sanctions.
"The reality is: That foreign exchange rate that you see reflects a lot of financial repression," Hassan Malik, a senior sovereign analyst at Boston-based investment management consultancy Loomis Sayles, told Insider. He was referring to a phenomenon where government policies are implemented to achieve certain economic outcomes, but at the cost of hindering the proper functioning of capital markets.
"The capital flow regime that operates in Russia today is totally different from what was operating in the beginning of February, prior to the invasion and prior to the sanctions," he added.
The Kremlin has devised programs to preserve jobs
Since Russia's invasion of Ukraine, international companies have been leaving the market in droves — but data from Rosstat shows employment holding steady around 4%.
That's mainly because the exodus has been orderly and "translating boardroom decisions into on-the-ground action takes time," Malik said. That's exactly what IBM, for one, did: In a memo to staff on May 30, IBM chairman and CEO Arvind Krishna announced an "orderly wind-down" of business in Russia.
"I attribute the persistence of relatively low levels of unemployment to labor-hoarding amongst state-influenced sectors, including by SOEs but also by foreign firms looking to engage in an orderly wind-down of their Russian operations," Malik said, referring to state-owned enterprises. The practice of "labor-hoarding" involves retaining more workers than a business needs rather than laying them off.
The Russian government has also been trying to preserve employment through implicit pressure on employers — a tactic Putin's regime has been using through the years, said Malik. This has contributed to a flurry of deals involving foreign companies selling their business and stakes in their Russian operations to local buyers who would continue running them under a different brand.
In May, for example, McDonald's sold its business in the country to a local licensee. The deal requires that the buyer continue employing and paying all of McDonald's staff in Russia for two years after the takeover, according to a McDonalds statement.
"Putin's stress on the headline unemployment rate in his recent Kremlin meeting with officials being low suggests to me that the strategy is to keep informal pressure on large employers to retain staff," said Malik.
The clock is still ticking for Russia
Even so, Russia may eventually run out of time when the commodities rally stall and as sanctions gnaw their way through the economy.
Elina Ribakova, the deputy chief economist at the Institute of International Finance, told Grid News that "within this year, we will see the effect on Russian economy as companies start to run out of parts or equipment and have to start laying people off or putting them on unpaid leave."
Russia's economy is expected to shrink 8.5% in 2022, with a further decline of 2.3% in 2023, the International Monetary Fund projected in an April report. That would be the economy's largest decline since the years following the fall of the Soviet Union in 1991.
- India's foreign exchange reserves fall to $573 bn
- India's retail inflation dropped below 7% in July for the first time in four months
- Samsung announces Galaxy Watch5 Series with sleep tracking and IR temperature sensor
- India's exports rose to $36 billion in July; trade deficit almost triples
- Rupee, bond yield ends almost flat ahead of the long weekend