This season of 'The Great British Baking Show' was a drama-filled disaster. Here's a timeline of all the controversies.
- "The Great British Baking Show," which just aired its season finale, had a lot of drama and controversies this year, both on-screen and off.
- It all started when one contestant, Sura, knocked over the technical challenge bake of another contestant, Dave, in the very first episode of the season.
- Things didn't improve as the season went on, between criticism of how the show handled cultural bakes on "Japanese Week" and online bullying directed at a finalist who stayed in the competition over an eliminated fan-favorite competitor.
- Insider compiled a timeline of all the controversies on this season of "The Great British Baking Show."
- Netflix didn't immediately respond to Insider's request for comment.
Warning: Spoilers ahead for "The Great British Baking Show."
"The Great British Baking Show" — or "Bake Off" if you're watching it in the UK — just aired this year's finale, capping off a season filled with drama and controversy from start to finish.The show, which has been on the air since 2010, has followed a similar format for the last 11 seasons: a group of home bakers are tested on their skills in the kitchen each week through three grueling rounds. At the end of each episode, one contestant is eliminated, while another is crowned "star baker," culminating in a face-off between the last three contestants in the finale episode.
Between a contestant accidentally ruining another's cakes to the show being criticized for its mishandling of cultural bakes, here's a definitive timeline of all the controversial moments on this season of "The Great British Baking Show."
Baker Sura accidentally slapped fellow baker Dave's cakes to the floor during 'Cake Week'"The Great British Baking Show" got off to a messy start this year. In the very first episode, "Cake Week," one contestant accidentally slapped a fellow baker's cakes to the floor.
For the technical round, the contestants were asked to present six identical pineapple upside-down cakes to judges Paul Hollywood and Prue Leith.As baker Sura placed her tray on the judging table, she tried to swat away flies from her cakes — and accidentally knocked fellow baker Dave's cakes to the ground in the process.
—British Bake Off (@BritishBakeOff) September 22, 2020Sura immediately and repeatedly apologized to Dave who remained calm and said "accidents happen."
To make matters even more awkward, Sura won first place in the challenge, while Hollywood called Dave's cakes "burnt and over caramelized" and noted that the issues with them had nothing to do with being dropped on the floor.
"It's bittersweet because I feel so sad for Dave. I wish it didn't happen to be honest," Sura said to the cameras after the challenge.Even the official Twitter account for the show chimed in with a tweet that jokingly asked viewers to "spare a thought for the tent carpet too!"
Both Sura and Dave were spared elimination that episode, but the moment got a lot of chatter among fans.
Viewers called out the Boris Johnson cold open on 'Cake Week' and the 'small hands' skit on 'Bread Week' as insensitive
In the earlier seasons of "The Great British Baking Show," original cohosts Mel Giedroyc and Sue Perkins started most episodes by trading banter while introducing the week's theme.The show has adopted a slightly different format in recent seasons: Before the competition begins, episodes often begin with an opening sketch. The brief scene typically features a pun, a corny play on words, or even elaborate costumes. They're goofy and sometimes cringeworthy, but not typically offensive.
Twitter users said that the very first cold open of the season — new cohost Matt Lucas' Boris Johnson sketch in the first episode's "Cake Week" — seemed to make light of the coronavirus pandemic, calling the bit "distasteful." The Independent reported that Ofcom, the UK government agency that regulates TV and broadcasting, had received more than 200 complaints about the bit.
—British Bake Off (@BritishBakeOff) September 22, 2020And there was more outcry after the "small hand" scene that opened the season's third episode, "Bread Week."
In the scene, cohosts Noel Fielding and Lucas pretend to discover a box containing the arm Paul Hollywood uses for his infamous handshakes, which he gives out to contestants on rare occasions to acknowledge exemplary bakes. Hollywood walks up and scolds them for messing around with his hand, showing off a fake tiny doll hand where his ordinary hand would usually be.The Independent reported that paralympian Carly Tait was among the viewers criticizing the show's use of a small prosthetic hand prop in the sketch, and Ofcom recorded 70 complaints about it.
—Carly Tait (@CarlyT_WcRacer) October 7, 2020"Oi @Channel4 do you need a #disabled expert or D&I consultant in your organisation as I would love to explain to you why the use of small hand as a comedy prop in #GBBO by @PaulHollywood IS NOT ACCEPTABLE," Tait tweeted.
Judge Paul Hollywood called rainbow bagels 'NHS bagels' during 'Bread Week'
During the third episode of the season, "Bread Week," the contestants were asked to make rainbow bagels in a technical challenge set by Hollywood.
"The rainbow colors, for me, although it originated over in the States, I think it represents the NHS for me," Hollywood said to Leith, speaking of the UK's National Health Service.Hollywood's comments didn't sit well with viewers. Mashed and MailOnline reported that Ofcom received complaints from viewers who were unhappy that Hollywood chose to associate the rainbow with the NHS rather than the LGBTQ community.
Forbes reported in May that during the pandemic, the rainbow flag has grown to become synonymous with the NHS, and some in the LGBTQ community felt uncomfortable with that.
Separately, other viewers took issue with Hollywood's idea of a bagel. Shannon Sarna of The Nosher criticized the time allotted to make the bagels and Hollywood's comments that a crispy bagel is "overdone.""I'm not sure he has ever visited New York City, or even tasted a bagel," Sarna wrote.
"I knew that to make a bagel in the total allotted time of 2 hours and 45 minutes was just ridiculous," Sarna wrote. "And the result of the bakers' bagels proved that it was a disaster."
The bakers struggled to conquer brownies during 'Chocolate Week'
—British Bake Off (@BritishBakeOff) October 14, 2020For the first challenge of the fourth episode's "Chocolate Week," the signature challenge, the bakers were tasked with making a batch of 18 chocolate brownies. And apparently, none of them quite knew what a brownie is supposed to be.
Fielding and the contestants echoed each other when pointing out that while brownies are easy to make, the time allotted, an hour and a half, makes things tricky."To get them cooked, cooled, and ready in an hour-and-a-half is going to be tough," baker Laura said to the cameras during the challenge."This, for me, is going back to basics. If you can't produce a decent chocolate brownie, there's going to be problems," Hollywood said.
The judges didn't seem impressed with any of the finished brownies.
Hollywood said Laura's Italian meringue brownies were "too sweet," baker Linda's brownies were like sponges rather than brownies, and that Lottie's batch looked like "they've been dropped.""We've all done a botched job of our brownies," contestant Sura admitted to the cameras after the challenge was over.
People took notice online too, with some calling the brownies challenge "an absolute disgrace."
—Yashar Ali (@yashar) October 21, 2020
—Lyn Mikel Brown (@LynMikel) November 19, 2020
—Helen Fulton (@HelenFulton) October 13, 2020
—Brigitte Bardont (@blondnotbomb) November 20, 2020
To be fair to the show's contestants, the brownie is an American treat — it's thought to have originated in Chicago in the early 1890s, according to Forbes — though it's still a popular treat in the UK.
Also during 'Chocolate Week,' judge Prue Leith angered New Yorkers with her babka comment
Some viewers took issue with how Leith praised Hollywood's version of the babka, saying the babka she had eaten in New York was "not nearly as nice as" the one Hollywood had made. While babka is said to have originated in eastern or central Europe, it's especially popular in New York City.Leith's comment prompted many people on Twitter to come to New York's defense, calling her remark "blasphemy."
—thembo support group (@motelamanda) October 17, 2020
—Dr. Tori (@vbarber820) October 17, 2020
Several fans tweeted that Leith clearly hadn't had real babka in New York, with many suggesting she try Breads Bakery, which is said to make New York City's best babka.Breads Bakery owner Gadi Peleg told Insider that babka is "part of the culinary language" of the city, and that he'd like for Leith to try it at his bakery.
Viewers said 'Japanese Week' was racistThe show attracted a lot of negative attention for its "Japanese Week" episode, with people on Twitter saying that the challenges didn't include a single traditional Japanese dessert. They also noticed that the contestants used pan-Asian ingredients which perpetuated the racist stereotype that all Asian cultures are the same.
—Mandana (@LimooTorshQueen) November 1, 2020
Twitter users also called out cohost Lucas for an insensitive comment when he jokingly pretended to mishear a contestant's katsu curry as "cat poo" curry.
—Lindsey Wasson (@lindseywasson) October 31, 2020
Insider spoke to pastry chef Tomoko Kato of Patisserie Tomoko, who didn't take an issue with the nontraditional ingredients and instead said that that Japanese cuisine has "room for both traditional and nontraditional" baking.Kato did add that it might be a good idea for the show to incorporate more traditional Japanese desserts, like the Japanese cheesecake, if they attempt a similarly themed episode in the future.
Baker Laura was harrassed online after she made it to the finals over fan-favorite baker Hermine in the semifinal 'Pâtisserie Week'
There's been no shortage of controversial eliminations over the course of the series' 11 seasons, where a fan-favorite contestant leaves the tent over another baker viewers think should have left instead. But few have sparked as much ire as Hermine being sent home over finalist Laura in the show's ninth episode, the "Pâtisserie Week" semifinal.
Fans were devastated over Hermine's elimination, which came after she opted to improvise her final showstopper challenge recipe and ended up with a lopsided cube cake "failure." Hermine was the season's last remaining baker who is a person of color.
—тαѕнα (@eds_shirtsleeve) November 17, 2020Some viewers upset by Hermine's departure turned on Laura, saying that they felt Hermine's track record was stronger than Laura's on the show. Laura became the target of online bullying, prompting her to speak out against her critics on twitter, writing: "It's ok to be sad your favourite person didn't go through, but please remember it's not my fault. I don't make the decisions."
—Laura Adlington (@LauraAdlington) November 18, 2020"It's easy to sit there on your sofa and judge,"Adlington wrote."But I am a real person with feelings. Please take a moment to consider your words before you judge someone you've never met and whose food you've never tasted."
—Laura Adlington (@LauraAdlington) November 18, 2020
Hollywood himself took to Instagram to ask viewers to "stop trolling" the bakers, reminding fans that "each week stands on its own" and that "it never matters what any baker has done in previous weeks" to explain why Hermine's stronger track record wouldn't have saved her over Laura.
Hermine similarly shared an Instagram post encouraging positivity and asking fans to "stop cyberbullying."
"Please don't be unkind in my name. I am all about #love and #kindness. Honor my time in GBBO by showing love and kindness. Behind what looks like characters on your tele are real people," she wrote.
Netflix didn't immediately respond to Insider's request for comment.
- CarbonWatch — India’s first mobile app to calculate your carbon footprint falls short of its promises
- Reddit recovers from a major outage as GameStop shares soar over 100%
- Nureca stocks debut on bourses at 59% premium over IPO price
- How Airtel’s AdTech platform is planning to deliver on the promise of ‘zero ad frauds’ to its clients
- Traffic jam on the Ganga - one of India's largest rivers will now get lane separators to deal with crowded boats