But some "Newsies" fans wanted Jack Kelly to be romantically involved with Davey (David Moscow).
Advertisement
Actor Ele Keats said she knew a lot of fans hated her character in "Newsies." But she didn't understand all of the reasons behind the ire until she spoke to Insider.
Keats played Sarah Jacobs, the love interest of Jack Kelly (Christian Bale) and sister of Davey Jacobs (David Moscow), in the 1992 film. Although the actor theorized that viewers disliked her character because she got to kiss the suave Jack Kelly, other fans felt she got in the way of what could have been a queer love story.
There are also hundreds of pieces of fan-fiction — stories written by fans that typically use characters from shows and movies — on Archive of Our Own and Wattpad that romantically pair Jack and Davey, or "Javid."
Upon learning of this pairing while speaking to Insider, she called it "fucking hilarious."
Advertisement
"'Cause David and Christian are the most heterosexual males, you know, it's funny," she said, adding she recently saw Moscow and his wife at her jewelry shop. "That is so freaking funny. I don't know if they know."
But she also called the fan-driven pairing "precious."
"If 'Newsies' is coming out today, there would be no problem whatsoever but it was the early 90s," she told Insider, adding, "I think that's sort of like a fan fantasy, you know?"
Keats said she dealt with a lot of negativity from 'Newsies' that went beyond dislike for her character
"It bombed. It was only in the theater for two weeks and the reviews are painfully mean," she said.
Advertisement
She told Insider Disney mailed her a "phone book of horrible reviews, including some personal-attack type of reviews" and it was "really hard" for her to read them.
"My character was hated," she said. "And there was just a lot of mean energy coming toward my character, but that correlates to 'I'm a human being and I feel those things.'"
She added that she felt "physically sick" right after "Newsies" and believes it has to do with all of the negativity.
But years later, she said, it's been "wonderful" to interact with "Newsies" fans.
"It's just such an amazing group of humans. I think if you love 'Newsies' you're just a good, openhearted loving person. It's not a scary fan group. It's definitely a love-filled, sweet group."
Advertisement
{{}}
NewsletterSIMPLY PUT - where we join the dots to inform and inspire you. Sign up for a weekly brief collating many news items into one untangled thought delivered straight to your mailbox.