Johnny Depp just spent 3 weeks painting Amber Heard as manipulative and abusive. Now it's time for Heard to tell her side of the story.
Advertisement
Ashley Collman,Jacob Shamsian
May 3, 2022, 22:56 IST
Johnny Depp and Amber HeardSteve Helber/Pool via REUTERS
Johnny Depp has rested his case against ex-wife Amber Heard in his defamation trial.
Depp, friends, and employees testified he controlled his liquor and Heard was abusive toward him.
Advertisement
For the past three weeks, a Virginia jury has heard from Johnny Depp — as well as a parade of the actor's family, friends, and employees — about his ex-wife Amber Heard's excessive drinking, argumentativeness, and penchant for treating him like a human punching bag.
Now it's time for Heard to tell her side of the story.
The former couple is currently locked in a high-profile defamation trial, centered on a 2018 Washington Post op-ed where Heard insinuated she had been the victim of domestic violence at Depp's hands.
Depp claims the article ruined his reputation and career and wants Heard to pay for it — to the tune of $50 million. In reality, Depp says, Heard abused him, mocking his weight and career and physically assaulting him throughout their relationship.
That's just the nature of a court trial. The plaintiff gets to present their witnesses first. The defendant gets to make their case after that. On Tuesday morning, Depp rested his case, so now it's Heard's turn.
In Heard's countersuit, she alleged Depp physically assaulted her in drug and alcohol-fueled rages on multiple occasions before and during their marriage. The relationship ended in divorce in 2016 after she showed up with a bruised face to a Los Angeles court and petitioned for a restraining order against Depp.
And we have every reason to believe that when Heard presents her case, there will be fireworks.
Johnny Depp has painted himself as a gentleman and Amber Heard as a vicious liar
The centerpiece of the trial so far has been the four days that Depp took the stand in the Fairfax County, Virginia courtroom. He told in his own words the story of his turbulent relationship with Heard.
Depp spoke at length about his childhood, and how having an abusive mother molded him into a pacifist. Whenever he was confronted with his erratic mother, and later Heard, he would try to extricate himself from the situation rather than rise to their provocations, he said.
Many of the other witnesses called to the stand corroborated parts of Depp's story. Depp's older sister said it wasn't in his nature to be abusive, because of what they had both experienced as children from their mother.
Depp has also preempted arguments from Heard's team in other ways. In his telling, Heard's lawyers have misrepresented his joking, exaggerated text messages about drug use and burning and drowning Heard's body in a way that make him look like a monster. He also said he lied about the circumstances of his finger getting cut off to medical professionals in order not to get Heard "in trouble." When Heard's lawyer cross-examined him, Depp was testy and downplayed or tried to raise doubts about audio and video recordings Heard took of the couple fighting.
Advertisement
Insider previously spoke to legal experts who said they felt Depp performed well on the stand.
"I think he did a good job of coming off vulnerable and authentic and truthful," entertainment lawyer Mitra Ahouraian said.
Depp's legal team has also gone on the offense, calling to the stand a forensic psychologist who evaluated Heard and testified she was prone to violence and making up stories, lining up with Depp's side of the story. An executive at the ACLU, too, testified that Heard failed to donate the money she promised from her divorce settlement with Heard, instead receiving some money from Elon Musk.
Amber Heard previously testified Depp 'threatened to kill' her
While Depp's legal team dug into the minutia of his relationship with Heard to try and cast doubt over her domestic violence claims, Heard's lawyers will no doubt try and steer the jury's mind back to the op-ed and whether the claims in it were essentially true. Heard has an advantage in this case because the burden is on Depp to prove that her allegations were false.
Advertisement
But there are other reasons why Depp may have brought this case. His career has waned because, he says, Heard unfairly ensnared him into the #MeToo movement. Winning this case, or at least airing out his side in full public in its entirety, may be the only way to clear his name.
The trouble is, he already tried that. In 2020, he went to trial against the owners of The Sun, a British tabloid, which called him a "wife beater," citing Heard's allegations. He lost that case, held in the UK, where libel laws are more favorable to plaintiffs than they are in the US. The judge wrote that Heard's claims about Depp were "substantially true."
Heard took the stand in the UK case. And if you look back at her testimony there, it spells bad news for Depp.
She testified in 2020 that Depp "explicitly threatened to kill" her, choked her, and falsely accused her of infidelity. He threw bottles at her as if they were "grenades," she said, on the night his finger got cut off in Australia. Depp later blamed his actions on a third-party, "the monster," in a way that deflected blame, according to Heard. Depp, in his testimony, gave a tortured explanation of how he used the phrase "monster," describing it as the term he used for his struggle to get sober.
Heard admitted to punching Depp once, but she said it was in self-defense. And the poop on the bed? She blamed it on her dogs.
Advertisement
A source close to Heard's legal team told Insider that her first witness will be Dawn Hughes, a clinical and forensic psychologist, who is expected to testify about domestic abuse.
After Hughes, Heard is expected to take the stand herself.
If he's used this case to rehabilitate his career, Depp hasn't succeeded just yet. While hordes of online fans have expressed their support, major studios aren't exactly running to sign him up for more blockbusters.
And when Heard testifies, Depp may learn that his efforts were for nothing.
Law & Crime Network host Jesse Weber says Depp still has an uphill battle towards victory in the case.
Advertisement
"It's becoming increasingly more difficult to show that there was no abuse. It's becoming increasingly more difficult to show that she lied in that 2018 article," Weber said.
{{}}
NewsletterSIMPLY PUT - where we join the dots to inform and inspire you. Sign up for a weekly brief collating many news items into one untangled thought delivered straight to your mailbox.