Many American Jews are worried Trump's decision to define Judaism as a nationality and not just a religion will do far more harm than good
MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty Images
- President Donald Trump reportedly plans to sign an executive order which will classify Judaism as a race or nationality instead of just a religion.
- Three administration officials told The Times that the order will threaten to withhold federal funding for colleges and universities who fail to combat discrimination on campuses.
- The loudest critics of the measure were Jews themselves, who say referencing Jews as a nationality will only further fuel anti-Semitic sentiment.
- Visit Business Insider's homepage for more stories.
President Donald Trump plans to sign an executive order which will classify Judaism as a race or nationality instead of just a religion, The New York Times reported on Tuesday, citing three administration officials.According to The Times, the order will threaten to withhold federal funding for educational bodies who fail to combat discrimination of minority students on their campuses.Advertisement
The move appears to be targeting the Boycott Divestment and Sanctions movement, or BDS, which encourages various forms of boycott against Israel for what it deems violations of international law. The movement has grown popular on college campuses, and the group holds annual events like "Israeli Apartheid Week" in order to push their agenda forward.
Though not all Jews are Israeli citizens, and not all Israeli citizens are Jewish, some Jewish groups argue that BDS activism fosters harassment or intimidation of Jews and Israel supporters on campus.Some critics have suggested that Trump's order might be used by the president to pander to Jewish constituents or as a goodwill gesture towards Israel (a close Trum ally), as the country's government has taken particular aim at combatting antisemitism and the BDS movement around the world.
Yousef Munayyer, the executive director of the US Campaign for Palestinian Rights, told The Times that the move could be used to stifle free speech and "silence Palestinian rights activism""Israeli apartheid apologists, Trump included, are looking to silence a debate they know they can't win," Munayyer said.
But notably, the group most vocally against Trump's measure appears to be Jewish people themselves.Halie Soifer, Executive Director at the Jewish Democratic Council of America, said Tuesday that Trump's executive order represented the "height of hypocrisy." Advertisement
"If President Trump truly wanted to address the scourge of anti-Semitism he helped to create, he would accept responsibility for his role emboldening white nationalism, perpetuating anti-Semitic conspiracy theories, and repeating stereotypes that have led to violence targeting Jews," she said in a statement. "Instead, President Trump continues to view Israel and anti-Semitism solely through a political lens, which he attempts to use to his political advantage."
"President Trump is more interested in symbolic gestures that politicize Israel and use Jews as political pawns than actually doing something meaningful to ensure our security and that of Israel," she continued. "The timing of this signing reveals this is a PR stunt, plain and simple."Other Jews expressed similar outrage on social media. Jewish actress and former "Saturday Night Live" cast member Michaela Watkins said on Twitter that Trump's reclassification of Judaism mirrored sentiments used by white nationalists and Nazi Germany. Advertisement
"This is antisemitism of the highest order," she wrote on Twitter.
Some said the move appears to question whether Jews are really American.Kelly Weill, a journalist for The Daily Beast, wrote on Twitter that the move "gestures at ethno-nationalizing American Jews right out of their country." Advertisement
Leah Litman, Assistant Professor of Law at the University of Michigan, tweeted that the order questions the nationality of American Jews.
"Is this what we're calling an executive order that purports to define American Jews as ... some nationality other than American?"Advertisement
Others said the move would put them in danger of anti-Semitic backlash.Others claimed the move in itself was anti-Semitic. The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Advertisement
The order comes at a time when violent anti-Semitic attacks have spiked to levels unseen in decades. According to researchers at Tel Aviv University in Israel, attacks targeting Jews around the world rose 13% in 2018, with more than 400 cases worldwide. Of those cases, one out of four took place in the United States.
According to the Anti-Defamation League, 1,879 anti-Semitic incidents were reported throughout the United States in 2018.
WHAT THE F*****************CK?- Michaela Watkins (@michaelaWat) December 11, 2019
Uh no. No. This is antisemitism of the highest order. No. No no no no no no NO. You, stupid crook president do not get to decide this so your white nationalist pals get to stick me in a concentration camp. https://t.co/PnQTxO5Cxg
So this makes American Jews citizens of which nation, then? https://t.co/ms5feeDTue- Michael Weiss (@michaeldweiss) December 11, 2019
all us formerly "American" Jews rn pic.twitter.com/RmimMaf6YI- danielle weisberg (@danielleweisber) December 11, 2019
This order will not protect our community from Trump's white nationalism or the violent threats we face. It will be used to target and silence human rights advocates and, in particular, Palestinian and Muslim college students.- IfNotNow (@IfNotNowOrg) December 11, 2019
This is horrifying, bigoted, and nonsensical.- Kris Shaffer ⏳ (@krisshaffer) December 11, 2019
Judaism ≠ Israel.
Jews are not un-American.
BDS is not (inherently) anti-Semitic.
Making American Jews choose between Israel and the U.S. *is* anti-Semitic.
So is not realizing that's what you're doing with this executive order.
- Best fitness bands in India to stay on top of your health
- Best budget Smart TV in India
- Best camera tripods for photography enthusiasts and learners
- Jupiter's mushball ammonia rain could explain the mystery behind shallow lightning storms in its atmosphere
- Global changes in land use is increasing the possibility of COVID-19 like outbreak, says a study